Payment difficulties on the client’s part
Article written for Byggcheferna.se
New arbitral award relating to the Serneke bankruptcy highlights the difficulties of assessing insolvency: what can contractors and subcontractors be expected to know about their client’s finances?
When a client encounters payment difficulties, the contractor faces difficult decisions. Suspending work can have costly consequences, but continuing also entails risks. And what happens if payments already received are later reclaimed? The ongoing clawback claims in the Serneke bankruptcy raise important questions for construction managers. Here, I explain the relevant rules and what you need to be aware of as the manager responsible. A new arbitral award relating to the Serneke bankruptcy highlights how difficult it can be to establish insolvency, even with extensive financial information. What, then, can reasonably be expected of a manager at a contractor or subcontractor with limited insight into the client’s finances?
The contractor must carry out the works in accordance with the contract, and the client must pay as agreed. An unjustified suspension of work or wrongful termination can result in substantial damages, while continuing work can increase credit risk. At the same time, a payment received may be subject to clawback. The responsible manager at the contractor or subcontractor must therefore make two important assessments in parallel: what measures does the construction contract permit, and what circumstances may be relevant if a payment is later challenged?
In my previous article, Payment difficulties and bankruptcy during an ongoing construction project – what you need to know, I discussed when work may be suspended, when contracts may be terminated and how a company can protect itself when the other party encounters payment difficulties. Here, I explore an issue raised by the Serneke clawback claims in greater depth: how should a contractor or subcontractor approach its obligation to perform the construction contract when even payments already received risk being reclaimed following a bankruptcy?
Clawback requires insolvency
The Serneke clawback claims are primarily based on Chapter 4, Section 5 of the Swedish Bankruptcy Act. For a payment to be recoverable under this provision, it must have improperly favoured the recipient over other creditors and caused detriment to at least one of them. The debtor, in this case the paying client, must have been insolvent or have become insolvent as a result of the transaction, either alone or in combination with another circumstance. Bad faith is also required: the recipient must have known, or ought to have known, both of the insolvency and of the circumstances that made the payment improper. All these requirements must be met, and the burden of proof rests with the bankruptcy trustee. A clawback claim is therefore not the same as an established obligation to repay.
Insolvency means that a company cannot pay its debts and that its inability to do so is not merely temporary. A late payment does not, in itself, establish insolvency. Nor are poor financial results or a lack of equity the same as insolvency. The decisive factor is the ability to pay.
The assessment must look forward from the point in time being examined. Which debts were due for payment, and what income, credit facilities or capital injections could the company expect? Were there realistic prospects of restoring its ability to pay within an acceptable period? The reason why an invoice remains unpaid also matters. Payment may not have been made because of a lack of funds, but it may also be because the invoice is disputed or there are counterclaims. Unpaid invoices must therefore be considered in context, while recurring delays and growing overdue debts can be important indicators of lasting problems.
An interesting arbitral award between Serneke’s former and current owners
An arbitral award was recently made public in a separate dispute between Serneke’s former and current owners, in which the issue of insolvency was considered. The award is binding only on the parties. In the clawback proceedings being heard around the country, each district court must independently assess the insolvency issue based on the evidence in the individual case.
That said, the award contains considerable criticism by the arbitral tribunal of the material on which the bankruptcy trustee based the assessment of when insolvency arose. Having considered the evidence presented in the arbitration as a whole, the tribunal found that the material was insufficient to establish insolvency and rejected the assertion that insolvency had existed as early as autumn 2023, the point in time relied on by the bankruptcy estate in the clawback disputes.
The award does not, in itself, mean that the clawback claims fail. The bankruptcy estate may continue to pursue them, and the requirements for clawback must be examined in each individual case.
What must the contractor investigate?
When assessing insolvency is clearly complicated, as in the Serneke bankruptcy, even with extensive financial information, the question arises as to what can reasonably be expected of a manager at a contractor or subcontractor with limited insight into the client’s finances. Two questions must be kept separate: whether the client was actually insolvent and whether the recipient of the payment knew or ought to have known this. The assessment concerns the information available at the time of payment and what a reasonable investigation would have revealed.
In certain circumstances, the recipient of a payment has a duty to investigate. This duty must be balanced against the interests of ordinary commercial dealings, meaning the interest in allowing normal business relationships to continue. The rules should not unnecessarily impede bona fide transactions or worsen the client’s financial situation. There must therefore be circumstances giving grounds to suspect insolvency, rather than merely a general risk of payment difficulties.
If the client proposes settling an invoice by means other than money, or wishes to change the payment terms, there may be reason to ask why. The same applies if the contractor already knows of payment difficulties or if information about financial problems has become known more widely. However, the assessment must not focus solely on warning signs. Information indicating that the payment problems can be resolved must also be considered, as must whether there are reasonable grounds for regarding earlier rumours as no longer relevant.
The fact that the contractor has not investigated further is not, however, sufficient to conclude that it ought to have known of the client’s insolvency. An investigation must also have been capable of revealing that the payment difficulties were not merely temporary. For the contractor, the question is not only why an invoice remains unpaid, but also what prospects the client has of catching up with payments.
Four steps for managers during an ongoing project
Investigate and follow up on warning signs. Obtain an up-to-date credit report, review the available financial information and request specific explanations of why payment is delayed and how future payments will be funded. Information about a financially strong owner may be relevant, particularly if that owner has previously provided funds. However, the owner’s financial strength is not the same as funding being available when it is needed. Follow up to check whether promised payments and capital injections actually materialise.
Check the grounds for suspension or termination. ABT 06 and AB 04 distinguish between a material failure to pay and insolvency of such a nature that the client cannot be expected to fulfil its obligations. In the event of late payment, it is necessary to establish, among other things, that the claim is clear and due for payment and that the client is not entitled to withhold payment. In the event of insolvency, the availability of adequate security is relevant to the right to terminate. Check the conditions and requirements for notices of default and written notifications under the contract actually in force. The duty to investigate under the clawback rules does not replace this contractual assessment.
Review security and new payment terms. Check the value and terms of any security and the issuer’s ability to pay before relying on it. Security provided by the debtor after the event for an existing debt may itself be subject to clawback. Changes to payment terms may require agreement and cannot simply be imposed unilaterally. Seek legal advice before entering into an urgent agreement or deciding to suspend work or terminate the contract.
Document both the supporting information and the decision. Keep payment histories, credit reports and correspondence about financing. Record what information was provided, by whom and when, how it was checked and why it was considered reliable or insufficient. Also retain construction contracts, payment schedules, supporting invoice documentation and records of work performed and continuing work. This makes it possible to explain retrospectively both the context of the payments and the considerations behind the decision to continue, suspend work or terminate the contract.
Do you want to know more? Contact:
Jennie Karlsson
Senior Associate | AdvokatCarousel items
-
Knowledge
11/19/2026
Payment difficulties on the client’s part
What should contractors know about their client’s finances? Explore insolvency, clawback risks and a new arbitral award relating to the Serneke bankruptcy.
-
Cases and transactions
11/4/2026
Lindahl advises HANZA on acquisition
Lindahl advised HANZA on the acquisition of the operations of five factories from Fortaco in Finland, Estonia and Poland.
-
News articles
10/14/2026
Lindahl once again recognised by IFLR1000
Lindahl is ranked in six practice areas in the latest IFLR1000 rankings, including a new ranking for Private equity. Seven of the firm's lawyers also receive individual recognition.
-
Portraits
7/3/2026
Jesper on business-oriented legal advice in energy: "It is not enough for the advice to be correct"
Lindahl's energy team is recognised in Legal 500 for combining deep regulatory expertise with broad commercial legal experience – find out how they support clients in a rapidly evolving sector.
-
Read more news and insights?