• About us
    • About Lindahl
    • How we work
    • Said about Lindahl
    • Press
    • Find us
    • Privacy
  • Areas
    • Commercial dispute resolution
    • IT/Tech
    • Intellectual property
    • Life Sciences
    • M&A
    • All areas
  • Our people
    • Stockholm
    • Göteborg
    • Malmö
    • Uppsala
    • Helsingborg
    • Örebro
  • Latest news
    • Cases and transactions
    • News
    • Events
    • Knowledge
    • Portraits
  • Offices
    • Stockholm
    • Göteborg
    • Malmö
    • Uppsala
    • Örebro
    • Helsingborg

The Land and Environment Court is the wrong forum for imposing fines

  • Home
  • Latest news
  • Knowledge
  • 2022
  • The Land and Environment Court is the wrong forum for imposing fines

On 8 June 2022, the Land and Environment Court of Appeal issued a ruling (case No. P 13945-21) on the correct forum for imposing fines in relation to supervisory decisions regarding street cleaning and signage.


Background

A building and traffic committee had ordered a property owner to remove advertising from a property on pain of a fine. The decision was made pursuant to section 12 of the Act containing special provisions on street cleaning and signage. The property owner appealed the decision before the county administrative board, which dismissed the appeal. The committee then applied to the Land and Environment Court for imposition of a fine. The Land and Environment Court approved the application, whereupon the property owner appealed the judgment and requested that the judgment be set aside and that the committee’s application be dismissed.

 

Judgment of the Land and Environment Court of Appeal

By setting aside the judgment of the Land and Environment Court, the Land and Environment Court of Appeal dismissed the committee’s application for imposition of a fine. The Land and Environment Court of Appeal, unlike the lower court, had noted the existence of specific rules regarding the forum for applications for imposition of fines. In its decision to dismiss, the Land and Environment Court of Appeal referred to the fact that the administrative court is the correct forum for an application for imposition of a fine. Another court, such as the Land and Environment Court, can only hear an application for imposition of a fine if such is specifically stipulated. This is set out in section 1(2) and section 6(1) of the Conditional Financial Penalties Act. Since the Land and Environment Court was not specifically designated as a forum for hearing applications for fines as a result of supervision under the Act on street cleaning and signage, the Land and Environment Court of Appeal set aside the judgment of the lower court and dismissed the committee’s application.

 

Comments

The decision of the Land and Environment Court of Appeal demonstrates how important it is for the supervisory authority to check which rules regarding forum apply before submitting an application for imposition of a fine. Since a large number of the supervisory cases dealt with by the country’s building committees must be heard by the Land and Environment Court, that need to check can be easily overlooked. As the above judgment shows, that leads to dismissal of the application. Provided that the two-year time limit for notification of an action for imposition of a fine is not exceeded, the committee could, in the case in question, apply for imposition of a fine for the infringement in question at the correct instance, i.e. before the administrative court. That is because no decision that has gained legal force has been issued on the matter.


Do you want to know more or did the article give rise to other questions? You are very welcome to contact any of us or your regular contact at Lindahl.

 

Environment

Lindahl is a leading firm in the field of environmental law offering lawyers who have vast experience of advising private and public clients in sectors such as energy, infrastructure, industry and research infrastructure. Many of our lawyers have worked at courts and environmental authorities or have professional experience from other European countries.

Visit page

Related

  • 2/1/2022 3:33:23 PM Our contribution to The Legal 500: Environment Country Comparative Guide
  • 1/19/2022 10:24:20 AM New ruling on lifting the corporate veil in the field of environmental law
  • 1/19/2022 6:04:49 PM Implementation of the new EU Drinking Water Directive
  • 2/15/2022 2:55:18 PM A restaurant receives environmental damages due to disturbances from the redevelopment of Slussen
  • 2/15/2022 3:30:29 PM News in climate adaptation
  • 2/15/2022 2:59:43 PM Changes to safety legislation affect many operators in the energy sector
  • 3/14/2022 3:31:28 PM One step closer to due diligence requirements in regard to sustainability
  • 3/15/2022 3:31:13 PM Environmental liability in connection with transfer of assets – new decision from the Land and Environment Court of Appeal

Contact

  • Johanna Lindqvist

    Göteborg

    [email protected] +46 731 472 781
  • Erika Sköld

    Göteborg

    [email protected] +46 706 371 063
Pages
  • Start
  • About us
  • Areas
  • Our people
  • Latest news
  • Privacy
Our offices
  • Stockholm [email protected] +46 8 527 70 800
  • Göteborg [email protected] +46 31 799 10 00
  • Malmö [email protected] +46 40 664 66 50
  • Uppsala [email protected] +46 18 16 18 50
  • Örebro [email protected] +46 19 20 89 00
  • Helsingborg [email protected] +46 42 17 53 00
Social media
  • Connect with us on social networks: Instagram, Linkedin, Youtube, Facebook,

Disclaimer

The material and information on this site is intended for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice on any specific matter. Please note that all images on Lindahl's website, www.lindahl.se, are subject to intellectual property protection and downloading, publication, copying and/or other use of the images requires the written consent of the rights holder. You'll find Advokatfirman Lindahl KB's general terms and conditions here.

Some cookies are essential, others help us improve your experience by providing insights into how the site is used. For more information, please visit our Cookie Policy.

Essential Cookies

These cookies are necessary for the functionality of the site and cannot be disabled.

Analytics Cookies>

We use Analytics cookies to collect information that gives us insight into how our website is being used. We anonymize IP addresses in Google Analytics. By clicking on Decline we won't save theese cookies.

Decline
We use cookies to get insights on how our site is used and give our visitors the best possible experience